Brooklyn Square Pizza

Brooklyn Square Pizza in Jackson Township, NJ, stands as a beacon of authentic Italian flavor and innovative pizza craft, expertly blending traditional Brooklyn-style with unique, creative twists that set it apart in the crowded pizza scene. This vibrant pizza and Italian restaurant invites guests into a warm, welcoming atmosphere where each dish promises an unforgettable experience filled with rich, comforting flavors and bold, inventive combinations.

At the heart of their menu is the iconic Brooklyn Square Pie — a signature creation defined by a delectably crispy crust that provides the perfect foundation for robust, perfectly seasoned sauce and a generous layer of melted cheese. But what truly elevates Brooklyn Square Pizza is the charming innovation behind offerings such as the Upside Down Pizza, where the toppings find a new harmony beneath a golden layer of cheese, delivering an unexpected texture and flavor profile that keeps diners coming back for more. The Honeymoon Pizza and Vodka Square Pizza are other standout selections, each boasting distinctive sauces and fresh, high-quality ingredients that sing in every bite.

For those craving classic Italian comfort food beyond pizza, dishes like Chicken Sorrentino, Chicken Parmigiana, and Seafood Diablo showcase the kitchen’s mastery over hearty, satisfying entrees steeped in rich sauces and authentic preparation. Delicate seafood options like Salmon Puttanesca and Shrimp Scampi add elegance to the menu, highlighting fresh flavors that balance perfectly with the more indulgent plates.

Start your meal with a selection from their tempting appetizers such as Fried Calamari, Zuppa Di Mussels with Red or White Marinara Sauce, or the crispy, savory Baked Clams. These dishes are thoughtfully crafted to awaken your palate and prepare you for the main event. For something more casual yet equally delicious, rolls and calzones offer options like Buffalo Chicken Roll or Spinach Roll, stuffed with generous fillings that are hearty and satisfying.

The panini menu is a revelation, featuring a variety of carefully assembled sandwiches like the Prosciutto Panini with SunDried Tomatoes & Smoked Mozzarella or the Grilled Chicken with Broccoli Rabe Panini. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of textures — from the crunch of the toasted bread to the melty, savory goodness within.

The dining experience at Brooklyn Square Pizza is punctuated by genuine hospitality — customers consistently highlight the attentive, friendly service and the personal touch of owner Peter Grippo, who is often present ensuring every guest feels welcomed and valued. Whether you're enjoying a cozy dinner or ordering catering for a special occasion, this establishment's commitment to quality and service shines through. One customer reminisced about catering a child's birthday party, praising the team’s professionalism and kindness from the first phone call through to the event itself, confirming that Brooklyn Square Pizza is a trusted partner in creating memorable moments.

It is no surprise that both locals and visitors alike regard Brooklyn Square Pizza as a top-tier destination for Italian dining in the area. Praise flows for the “crisp crust,” “amazing sauce,” and “pizza royalty” status it holds, with some even suggesting the place rivals its namesake borough in authenticity and flavor. This vibrant spot offers more than a meal — it offers a slice of Brooklyn heart and soul right in New Jersey, a place where each dish tells a story and every visit feels like coming home.

If you’re seeking a restaurant where bold, traditional flavors meet creative flair, and where warmth both on the plate and from the staff invites you to savor every bite, Brooklyn Square Pizza is an exceptional choice. Their menu reads like a love letter to Italian comfort food, executed with skill and passion that leaves a lasting impression on your palate and your heart.